I didn’t set out to write the song knowing I would give it the “Queen of Hearts” title. My song’s title wasn’t in my head when I wrote the first line, “She was sitting underneath a tree beside Olaton Road.”
I had an image in my mind of an innocent young maiden in trouble and a young lad coming to the rescue. What a new concept! Right? Good thing that’s never been done before. Ha!
That’s maybe the most difficult thing about songwriting, finding a fresh way to sing about a theme or plot that’s been addressed a million times over.
There are no new themes to be had; what was there in the beginning is all we have to work with still today. All a songwriter can do is rework what was written in times gone by.
Go on YouTube today, and you’ll discover songs with that “Queen of Hearts” title from just about every genre of music, from country to southern rock to thrash metal. And Bluegrass!
In 2024, Lonesome River Band released their latest album The Winning Hand and one of the tracks is “Queen of Hearts”, written by their mandolin/vocalist Adam Miller and guitar/vocalist Jesse Smathers.

I love the song, but I’m going to love just about anything they do because I happen to be an LRB freak.
Miller and Smathers did manage to approach the subject in a somewhat newer light. Their protagonist is a man with two loves: a woman and poker, both queens of hearts. The woman he loves is a good queen of hearts, but he doesn’t know if he can avoid the other queen of hearts, the bad one, gambling.
Either way, he must give up one to have the other. It’s a take on the theme of temptation and destruction.
Joan Baez had a “Queen of Hearts” song in 1965. Gregg Allman wrote one in ‘73. And there have been many others since.
The most well-known “Queen of Hearts” song is Hank DeVito’s masterpiece. It was first recorded in 1979 by Dave Edmunds. Ten years later in ‘89, Rodney Crowell recorded it.
The most famous version, however, was recorded in ‘81 by Juice Newton. I might have had the 45 back in the day. For you younguns, that’s a record that spins at 45 rpm.

(from Google Images)
Here’s an interesting examination of the subject: When people hear those words, “queen of hearts,” which comes to mind more, Newton’s “Queen of Hearts…or the Queen of Hearts character in Lewis Carrol’s 1865 book Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland?

(from Google Images)
For certain the Queen of Hearts has become entrenched in our culture. And it didn’t start with Lewis Carrol’s book because his story is based on a 1782 British nursery rhyme with the same title.
Oh, but wait! That nursery rhyme is itself based on the face cards in a deck of playing cards. And according to Wikipedia, the Queen of Hearts playing card may date back to pre-1440 Germany.
So the Queen of Hearts has had centuries to become a part of us.
At some point while writing my “Queen of Hearts” song, which started as a “boy saves girl” tale, the thought occurred to me—what if she wasn’t really in trouble but was deceiving the boy?
The “what if” question is a valuable one for you writers out there!
I have no earthly idea why I redirected toward the themes of betrayal and manipulation. And once I decided her suffering was a ruse, I don’t recall the moment it came to my mind to see her as a queen of hearts and make that the title.
One long shot explanation could be Tom Petty. What? Huh?
You see, in the 80’s I listened regularly to his songs, like “American Girl,” “Refugee,” “Mary Jane’s Last Dance, “ and “Free Fallin’.”
Maybe you still haven’t made the connection? Here, let me drop some breadcrumbs…the 80’s marked the birth of music videos and cable channels like MTV and CMT.
Petty released his Southern Accents album in 1985. The first song on that album was “Don’t Come Around Here No More,” written by Petty and Dave Stewart from the Eurythmics. If you saw the music video on MTV—and remembered it—the light bulb in your brain would light up brightly. Aha!

(from Google Images)
Though the song had no obvious mention of Alice or anything else to do with Carrol’s classic, the bizarre and controversial video featured Alice, the Mad Hatter, the Caterpillar, and one extremely Mad Tea Party. But the Queen of Hearts character is nowhere to be seen.
Cowriter Dave Stewart has always claimed the idea for the video came from a Stevie Nicks party, the same party where the song idea originated.
At any rate, when I made the girl in my song the opposite of innocent, could a long ago memory of a Tom Petty video have sparked something in my mind? I don’t really think so, but you never know.
I suppose it all traces back to Carroll’s fantastical story about Alice, for it was Carroll who first made the Queen of Hearts a villain.
Science still doesn’t know all that much about our brains and our imaginations, except that we all have them. In the end it boils down to billions of cells upstairs producing chemicals and electricity.
Finally, here’s what my brain cells came up with about a week ago.
Queen of Hearts
She was sitting underneath a tree beside
Olaton Road
Weeping uncontrollably while she was all alone
My heartstrings, they all complained, they yearned to save the miss
That all her tears were false…oh, how was I to guess
I helped her up, I held her close, I dried her tears away
Lady, what has gone awry to make you mourn today
Woe is me, she sighed and said, my honor I have lost
A man I loved, I thought loved me, our child and me he crossed
She played my heart like a string on her fiddle
She knew the part, she knew how rue to kindle
All the world’s a stage, they say, and so the story goes
She’s the wily queen, the Queen of Hearts you know
The man she claimed a rogue I caught, I wore him up and down
I found him mumbling by himself, the other side of town
He wailed about the Queen of Hearts, she’d made him for a fool
She cleaned him out…he cried, oh, God, she’s cruel
She played my heart like a string on her fiddle
She knew the part, she knew how rue to kindle
All the world’s a stage, they say, and so the story goes
She’s the wily queen, the Queen of Hearts you know